SEBI: True to Label

This edition of Weekly Olio is brought to you by Intercom.

Intercom for Startups

Join Intercom’s Early Stage Program to receive a 90% discount.

Get a direct line to your customers. Try the only complete AI-first customer service solution.

Apply now

The Quote󠀢 💭

The Tweet 🐦

If Peter Thiel's circle (enter David Sacks) are the forces of Mordor, Paul Graham is the kind Gandalf of Silicon Valley leading the fellowship. PG has always been founder-first and everyone at YC and in the Valley adores him. A coup against the founder of Zenefits and Rippling? The most-evil person in silicon valley? 👀

The Short Read 📝

Software led GBO deals - by Slow Ventures

Slow Ventures is an early-stage focused Venture Capital firm based out of San Francisco, Boston, and New York. It is a generalist fund and invests in early stage teams and ideas ranging from Social Networking to Consumer Brands to SaaS, and Crypto.

Software, not B2B SaaS, will eat the world - build software, and then just buy your customers. Check the deck to follow along, and keep scrolling to get a preview of how they got here. Worth a flip if you haven't seen it already.

The Long Read 📜

Behind the Stream: JioCinema’s Workflow for Major Events - by JioCinema

Most of us have shot video. Some of us even regularly share videos from our lives and don't even blink. How different can streaming a live event be? The short answer is - very.

Hundreds of cameras, hundreds of personnel on ground, in the studios, at the playout and hundreds of eyes before it reaches yours.

Streaming video content at scale to millions of customers simultaneously is not the same as shooting a video on your phone and uploading it to a social network, nor is it as convenient as just handing off to a CDN. This article covers a 100K view some of the things that go into bringing the precious moment when your team wins without a stutter.

This edition of Publisher’s Parmesan is brought to you by Beehiiv.

Wondering how you can write multiple newsletters, without spending hours managing editions? 

The beehiiv Ad Network delivers 800 million impressions a month across hundreds of the world's top newsletters, paid on performance. 

Our managed service enables you to unlock newsletters as a growth channel without the added time. 

Publisher’s Parmesan 🧀

SEBI: True to Label

India’s capital markets regulator, SEBI, has issued a directive to online brokerages to abandon slab pricing for clients and adopt a uniform charge system. This move has sweeping implications for fintech startups in the online stock brokerage space. Companies like Zerodha, Groww, and Shoonya, renowned for their zero brokerage models, face potential revenue disruptions and valuation shifts. As SEBI continues to enforce stringent regulations aimed at enhancing market accountability and oversight, how will these fintech players adapt?

This article explores the ripple effects of SEBI's mandate, the strategic pivots these companies might need to make, and whether this is part of a broader regulatory trend targeting online brokers. We'll delve into the potential changes in business models, the impact on customer acquisition and retention, and the overall future of the online brokerage landscape in India.

A recent mandate from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is set to shake up the revenue streams and perhaps even the valuations of fintech startups operating as online stock brokers. So, what exactly is this new mandate?

On July 1st, SEBI issued a circular with a rather telling title: "True to Label." This mandate affects market infrastructure institutions, including stock exchanges and depositories. The core instructions are clear:

Additionally, SEBI has banned the practice of slab-wise charges for brokers, where higher trading volumes previously led to lower fees. This move aims to standardize and flatten the fee structure across the board. But why is SEBI doing this, and what does it mean for the booming sector of discount brokers?

The Rationale Behind SEBI’s Mandate

The primary driver behind SEBI's decision appears to be a desire for increased transparency and fairness in the financial markets. The regulator has been scrutinizing the sector closely, particularly the exponential growth in the futures and options segment, which has led to concerns about excessive speculation. SEBI’s goal is to protect retail investors by ensuring that the market operates in a transparent, honest, and equitable manner.

This is not an isolated step. SEBI has previously issued multiple directives to curb regulatory arbitrage and ensure that the industry operates without taking undue advantage of loopholes. The overarching aim is to create a more accountable and strictly regulated trading environment. But how did we get here?

The Rise of Discount Brokers

Zerodha, the pioneer in this space, revolutionized the market back in 2015 by offering zero brokerage on deliveries against securities. This move opened up a new segment in India, attracting a slew of imitators. Platforms like 5paisa and Angel One followed suit, positioning themselves as zero-cost, tech-first brokers.

The COVID-19 pandemic further accelerated the growth of these new-age discount brokers. With an influx of new market participants, platforms like Groww saw a surge in user numbers, quickly becoming the number one broker in terms of active customers. These discount brokers carved out significant market share, largely due to their appeal to young, tech-savvy traders looking to bet big in the risky futures and options market. But how will SEBI's new mandate impact these companies?

Immediate and Long-term Impacts on Revenue

The full extent of the impact is still being assessed by the industry. However, initial estimates suggest that the new mandate could affect 15 to 30 percent of the top line for these brokers. Nitin Kamath, CEO of Zerodha, has publicly stated that the move could impact 10 percent of his company's revenue, while industry-wide impacts could be as high as 50 percent, depending on various factors.

This significant potential hit to revenue means that brokers will need to innovate and diversify their income streams. While transaction charges have been a major revenue source, brokers also make money from account opening fees, margin funding, and other ancillary services. The challenge will be to find new revenue avenues while complying with the new regulatory framework.

Broader Industry Concerns

The mandate signals that SEBI is not done with its regulatory tightening. Brokers are understandably worried about further interventions that could clamp down on other revenue streams. The days of easy money are over, and life as a broker is set to become increasingly regulated.

A significant concern is how traders will react to these changes. Traders tend to be loyal to their brokers due to habitual use, but the impact of passing on these charges to the end customer remains uncertain. Will traders stick with their current brokers, or will they shift to larger, full-service brokers like ICICI Securities?

The Changing Landscape of Broking

So, what used to happen earlier and what will change now? Under the current system, brokers can charge transaction fees based on multiple slabs determined by the turnover executed in different segments at the end of the month. This allowed brokers to pass on higher costs to clients based on the highest slab executed. The new system will require brokers to charge customers a defined amount set by the exchanges, eliminating the slab-based pricing model.

This change will not only impact discount brokers but the entire broking industry. The industry, which operates on a revenue pool of roughly 40,000 to 45,000 crores, could see a significant outflow of revenue due to the new mandate. Estimates suggest a 5 to 8 percent overall hit, which could translate to a 5 to 50 percent impact on individual brokers’ top lines, particularly those heavily reliant on transaction-linked income.

Future of the Fintech Broking Model

Discount brokers, especially those with a significant reliance on rebate-based models, might face the brunt of this regulatory change. However, they might also see consolidation in the industry, leading to mergers and acquisitions over the next few years. Innovation in revenue streams and service orientation will be critical for these brokers to stay competitive.

Despite being a zero-cost broker, the diversified revenue model of firms like Zerodha, which generates income from account opening fees, margin pledges, and advisory services, could provide a buffer against these regulatory changes. Brokers will need to enhance their service offerings and technology expertise to retain and attract clients.

Impact on Traders and Investors

For traders and investors, the direct financial impact of these changes may be minimal. The new charges are unlikely to deter day traders or long-term investors significantly. However, there could be a small impact on futures and options trading, counterintuitive to SEBI’s goal of curbing retail participation in these speculative segments.

Conclusion: A New Era of Regulation

As SEBI continues to tighten its regulatory grip, the fintech broking industry stands at a crossroads. Will this nimble-footed breed of fintech brokers adapt to the new landscape, or will they struggle under the weight of increased regulation? The answer lies in their ability to innovate, diversify, and maintain transparency in an ever-evolving market. Only time will tell how these changes will reshape the industry, but one thing is certain: the era of easy money in broking is over, and a new, more accountable phase has begun.